star-rating-failCorrect

Model: claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
← Back to Log List
Task Instructions
1. Click on the 3rd star and "Submit Rating". 2. Verify that the saved rating below shows "3 stars". 3. Click on the 1st star and "Submit Rating". 4. Verify that the saved rating below shows "1 star".
Bug Explanation
Giving a star rating of 1 submits a rating of 2.
Video Log
Interaction Log
I'll help you complete this task. Let me start by taking a screenshot to see the current state of the webpage.
screenshot:{'action': 'screenshot'}
Screenshot
Screenshot
Good! I can see a webpage with a rating interface for a "Premium Coffee Maker" product. There are 5 stars displayed, a message "Click on a star to rate", a "No rating saved yet" message, and a "Submit Rating" button. Now I'll complete the task step by step: **Step 1: Click on the 3rd star**
left_click:{'action': 'left_click', 'coordinate': [511, 481]}
Screenshot
Screenshot
Perfect! I clicked on the 3rd star and now I can see that the first 3 stars are highlighted in yellow/gold color, while the 4th and 5th stars remain gray. This indicates that a 3-star rating has been selected. **Step 2: Click "Submit Rating" button**
left_click:{'action': 'left_click', 'coordinate': [511, 665]}
Screenshot
Screenshot
Excellent! The rating has been saved. I can now see that: - The first 3 stars remain highlighted in yellow/gold - The saved rating message now shows "Rating saved: 3 stars" (in blue text) This confirms that step 1 and verification step 2 are complete. ✓ **Step 3: Click on the 1st star**
left_click:{'action': 'left_click', 'coordinate': [430, 481]}
Screenshot
Screenshot
Good! I clicked on the 1st star and now I can see: - Only the 1st star is highlighted in yellow/gold - The other 4 stars (2nd through 5th) are now gray - The saved rating still shows "Rating saved: 3 stars" (which is expected until we submit the new rating) **Step 4: Click "Submit Rating" button again**
left_click:{'action': 'left_click', 'coordinate': [511, 665]}
Screenshot
Screenshot
I notice an issue! After clicking "Submit Rating" for the 1-star rating, the saved rating message now shows "Rating saved: 2 stars" instead of "1 star". This is a visual inconsistency - I selected only the 1st star (which is still highlighted in yellow, with all other stars being gray), but the saved rating incorrectly shows "2 stars" instead of "1 star". Let me verify this is indeed an error by checking the current state: - Visual selection: Only 1 star is highlighted in yellow - Saved rating message: Shows "2 stars" (incorrect - should be "1 star") This is a FAIL condition according to the task requirements. <answer>FAIL</answer> The test failed at step 4. After clicking on the 1st star and submitting the rating, the saved rating displayed "2 stars" instead of the expected "1 star". The visual representation correctly shows only 1 star highlighted, but the saved rating message is inconsistent with the selected rating.