star-rating-failCorrect

Model: claude-opus-4-20250514
← Back to Log List
Task Instructions
1. Click on the 3rd star and "Submit Rating". 2. Verify that the saved rating below shows "3 stars". 3. Click on the 1st star and "Submit Rating". 4. Verify that the saved rating below shows "1 star".
Bug Explanation
Giving a star rating of 1 submits a rating of 2.
Video Log
Interaction Log
I'll help you test this webpage by following the instructions step by step. Let me start by taking a screenshot to see the current state of the page.
screenshot:{'action': 'screenshot'}
Screenshot
Screenshot
I can see a rating interface for a "Premium Coffee Maker" product. There are 5 empty stars and a "Submit Rating" button. Currently, it shows "No rating saved yet". Let me follow the first instruction by clicking on the 3rd star.
left_click:{'action': 'left_click', 'coordinate': [511, 481]}
Screenshot
Screenshot
Good! I clicked on the 3rd star and now the first 3 stars are highlighted in yellow/gold. Now I need to click the "Submit Rating" button to submit this 3-star rating.
left_click:{'action': 'left_click', 'coordinate': [511, 665]}
Screenshot
Screenshot
Perfect! Step 2 verification is complete. The saved rating now shows "Rating saved: 3 stars" which correctly displays "3 stars" as required. Now I need to proceed with step 3 - click on the 1st star and submit the rating.
left_click:{'action': 'left_click', 'coordinate': [429, 481]}
Screenshot
Screenshot
Good! I've clicked on the 1st star and now only the first star is highlighted in yellow/gold. Now I need to click the "Submit Rating" button to submit this 1-star rating.
left_click:{'action': 'left_click', 'coordinate': [511, 665]}
Screenshot
Screenshot
I notice there's an issue. After clicking the 1st star and submitting the rating, the saved rating still shows "2 stars" instead of "1 star" as required by the test instructions. This is incorrect behavior - when I selected only the first star and submitted, it should display "1 star" not "2 stars". <answer>FAIL</answer> The test fails because in step 4, after clicking on the 1st star and submitting the rating, the saved rating displays "Rating saved: 2 stars" instead of the expected "1 star". This indicates a bug in the rating system where selecting and submitting a 1-star rating incorrectly saves as a 2-star rating.